Review - Boots No7 Beautiful Skin Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover & Botanics All Bright Soothing Eye Makeup Remover

After my less than glowing review on Boots No7 Beautiful Skin Eye Makeup Remover, I was sent two other eye makeup removers from Boots. I appreciate the opportunity to take another look at their eye makeup removers because I doubt that I would have otherwise. I might have just concluded that Boots was a brand for my favorite toner and exfoliator, but not for eye makeup removers. Luckily, that opinion of mine is quite different now.

Boots Botanics All Bright Soothing Eye Makeup Remover (L)

Boots No7 Beautiful Skin Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover (R)

No7 Beautiful Skin Oil Free Makeup Remover is, well, the oil free version available from Boots.

Except that the product description says "it removes even waterproof mascaras" (because it does not), there is nothing wrong with this eye makeup remover.
I think Boots should re-lable this product asap, so the customers won't be misled (and end up ranting about it).

For an oil-free eye makeup remover designed for sensitive eyes and skin, it is a fine product. It removes regular mascaras with no irritation. It feels cool and soothing on contact.

In fact, this remover feels a lot like micellar water. You know how micellar water kind of removes stubborn eye makeup but not entirely? It is just like that and it does work on foundation removal. (Yes, I have tried it. No issues.)

On the other hand, Boots Botanics All Bright Soothing Eye Makeup Remover is a clear winner. 

I am thoroughly impressed by this bi-phased remover to see it removes my waterproof mascara quickly and gently. This actually came with a recommendation note from Boots team, and now I understand why.

This taller and slender bottle is better to hold, and it does not have the "mixing" problem like the No7. I also like that All Bright Soothing Eye Makeup Remover does not contain artificial colorants and it is even cheaper than No7 removers. 

I would highly recommend this if you're looking for an affordable yet effective eye makeup remover.

Have you tried these eye makeup removers from Boots?

What is your experience with them?

Shop The Post

*Disclosures*